Thu. Sep 21st, 2023

Happy break time. 

Perhaps you’re celebrating a break from school or a break in which you can watch various countries prepare their national teams for the winter World Cup. Or maybe you’re enjoying a break from watching a downward trending Minnesota United play soccer. 

(Regardless of how many of those boxes you check, we won’t judge.)

Because we’ve got a nice little break on our hands, there is no better thing to do than revisit the 14 matches that the Loons have played from a statistical perspective. Numbers don’t tell the whole story, but they do tell a story — and that’s enough to get us through the break.

Might Dayne’s gloves get the Midas touch?

Dayne St. Clair has emerged as United’s best goalkeeper after a rather short battle for the starting job. That might be because he’s emerged as the best goalkeeper in MLS as a whole.

Matt Doyle, who analyzes the league for its content arm, has pointed out St. Clair as a runaway favorite for MLS’ top goalkeeping honor while suggesting the Canadian deserves some mention in the MVP race, too.

The numbers back this up. St. Clair has “added” 5.84 goals to this Minnesota team through his play, the most of any ‘keeper in the league, according to American Soccer Analysis. As expected, the vast majority of that has come from shotstopping actions, or saves.

He’s conceded only 71% of the goals that he would be expected to, ASA has determined, which is tied for the best proportion in the league. 


If you want to see that does for a team: The Loons’ opponents have generated 21.82 expected goals, the 5th most in the league. And yet they’ve only scored 14, giving United the 4th stingiest defense. 

St. Clair’s saves have largely inverted Minnesota’s defensive standing in the league.

(One notable area where he remains middle of the pack is distribution. For every 100 passes he takes, he misses the target on about three more than expected, according to ASA’s model. That shakes out to a little less than one per game.)

Ope, you dribbled

I have waxed poetic about the dribbling ability of Minnesota in the past, but it seems that habit has caught up with the Loons. 

Attacking midfielder Emanuel Reynoso still has completed the most successful dribbles and dribbled past the most players in the league, but he’s fallen in the nutmeg rankings to be tied for fourth. 

Is it a sign of the times? Perhaps. 

ASA’a goals-added metric suggests Reynoso’s dribbling has been a slight detriment to Minnesota, racking up a -0.11 tally so far. Robin Lod’s the fourth-costliest player in the dribbling market with -0.7. 


What does that mean? A number of things, probably, but one of them perhaps being that the Loons are perhaps over-relying on dribbling as a way to advance the ball. While dribbling through open space remains the most effective way to get the ball up the pitch, an opposing team catching on to the trend can make it… less effective.

Minnesota has, so far, been one of the not-so-great teams when it comes to passing the ball. Collectively completing 77.5% of their passes means only six teams do so at a worse rate than the Loons.

This is a horrific oversimplification of how soccer works, but maybe a general idea would be to dribble less and pass more. Or tell El Rey to nutmeg dudes more frequently — whatever works.

Courtesy MNUFC

Bouncin’ around

  • Luis Amarilla hasn’t played a whole lot (831 minutes, an average of about an hour per game), but ASA’s goals-added model gives him the 5th worst tally in MLS of all field players. That metric suggests the striker has cost Minnesota 1.42 goals in his time on the field. Does that get added onto the 25? (I kid. And also hope that the strikers start scoring soon.)
  • Don’t look now, but two former Loons are doing pretty well in that goals-added area. Former defender Francisco Calvo, now with the San Jose Earthquakes, is fourth, while Reynoso predecessor Darwin Quintero sits 11th for the Houston Dynamo.
  • Minnesota is one of five teams not to have received a red card this season.

That’s probably a jinx, which means it’s time to be done. Stay safe in the world and reasonable on the internet. 

Oh, and subscribe to SotaSoccer’s Patreon for even more sweet content on the Loons, Aurora and lots of local soccer.

By Eli Hoff

Eli is a Washington, D.C. correspondent for the Columbia Missourian and Missouri News Network, where he anchors a one-reporter bureau that provides breaking news and enterprise stories to more than 200 newspapers. The New York Times highlighted his “dogged” reporting in a 2020 feature about his coverage of Covid-19 and Greek Life at the University of Missouri. He’s been developing that journalistic skill since he launched a soccer news site at the age of 14. In the seven years since, Eli has reported on national and state politics, sports, national security, education and public health. Eli’s work has appeared in Major League Soccer, SB Nation, the Columbia Daily Tribune, the Jefferson City News Tribune, Vox Magazine and been syndicated by the Associated Press. His versatile skillset — including investigative reporting, feature writing and documentary production — has been honored by the Associated Press Sports Editors and Missouri College Media Association. He’s no stranger to using public records, having filed more than 100 records requests with 27 states and several federal agencies. But Eli also brings an eye for unconventional and human stories to his work, combining scoop generation and longform skill. Before his work in Washington, Eli covered varied topics as part of the Columbia Missourian’s higher education team, ranging from a fraternity hazing case and hospital security violations to the myth of an escaped research monkey.

Leave a Reply

%d bloggers like this: